Three songs from Christmas Carol adaptations moved on. They’ve got some good songs.
(1) Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas from Meet Me in St. Louis vs. (4) Oh What a Merry Christmas Day from Mickey’s Christmas Carol
The biggest winner in Round 1 (by a score of 96-4), this classic from Meet Me in St. Louis has a pretty good chance to move into the third round.
Outside of the cartoon, it’s not necessarily all that great, but it really is a nice, atmospheric start to Mickey’s Christmas Carol.
(2) Thank You Very Much from Scrooge vs. (6) When Love is Gone from A Muppet Christmas Carol
Not only this is the most hilarious, upbeat song about death this side of “Always Look on the Bright Side of Life,” it also features the brilliant lyric “But since I left my cannon at home.” I hate when that happens. This is a fantastic song, yet it’s featured in one of the worst Christmas Carols.
This is one of the toughest matches yet, because both songs are truly great. I cannot grasp why this song was cut from A Muppet Christmas Carol.
Movie Match-Up 
One thought on “Best Christmas Song: Movies (Round 2)”